The 3% Nobody Notices
When a vendor delivers 970,000 impressions against a 1,000,000 commitment, the 3% shortfall is worth real money. But in most organizations, nobody notices — because nobody is checking delivery against commitment until the campaign is over.
By then, it's too late to act. The vendor has moved on. The campaign is done. The make-good that should have been claimed never was. And the 3% becomes a permanent line item in the budget leakage column.
Under-delivery is not rare. It happens on almost every campaign, to some degree. The question isn't whether it happens — it's whether you have a framework to catch it, claim compensation, and hold vendors accountable.
What a Make-Good Is
A make-good is the vendor's compensation for under-delivery. It can take several forms:
- Additional inventory — the vendor delivers more impressions in a later flight to make up the shortfall
- Credit — the vendor issues a credit note against future buys
- Refund — the vendor refunds the undelivered portion of the spend
The make-good is the vendor's acknowledgment that they didn't meet the committed volume. Without a delivery record that shows the shortfall, there's nothing to claim against.
The Vendor Accountability Framework
A vendor accountability framework has four components:
1. Commitment recording. The IO records the committed volume — the number of impressions, clicks, or actions the vendor promised to deliver. This is the baseline.
2. Delivery tracking. As the campaign runs, actual delivery is recorded against the IO line. This is the comparison. When actual delivery falls below commitment, the shortfall is visible.
3. Pacing alerts. Before the campaign ends, pacing checks flag under-delivery while there's still time to act. The vendor can be asked to adjust delivery, or the shortfall can be documented for a make-good claim.
4. Make-good claims. When delivery falls short, a make-good claim is filed against the vendor. The claim references the IO, the committed volume, the actual delivery, and the shortfall. The vendor's response — credit, additional inventory, or refund — is recorded against the claim.
Why Most Organizations Don't Do This
Most organizations don't have this framework because it requires connecting three things that usually live in separate places: the IO (which has the commitment), the delivery report (which has the actuals), and the invoice (which has the payment). When these are connected, the shortfall is obvious. When they're not, it's invisible.
The other reason is that make-goods are uncomfortable. Claiming a make-good means telling a vendor they didn't deliver what they promised. It's easier to let the 3% slide than to have that conversation. But over a year, across hundreds of placements, 3% adds up to a significant amount of money.
Valuing Make-Goods
When a make-good is claimed, it's valued at the negotiated rate — not the rate card price. This is where commercial terms matter. If the negotiated rate was $4.50 CPM and the shortfall is 30,000 impressions, the make-good value is $135. Without the commercial term, the value is unclear — and the vendor might offer a make-good at the rate card price, which is less than what you actually paid.
The Bottom Line
Under-delivery is a fact of media buying. Vendors will sometimes deliver less than they committed. The question is whether you notice, whether you claim compensation, and whether you can prove the shortfall. A vendor accountability framework makes all three possible — and it starts with connecting your IOs to your delivery records.